Colt's new service

American Handgunner, July-August, 2005 by John Taffin

Still producing percussion revolvers in 1869, Colt was caught off guard as Smith & Wesson introduced the future. It was the Model #3 .44 S&W American chambered not for ball and powder that loaded from the front of the cylinder, but in actuality was the first big bore cartridge firing revolver. It would be three years before Colt could legally override Smith & Wesson's patent, and the result was the Single Action Army of 1873. Colt apparently learned their lesson from this episode and would not be caught napping with the next wave of handgun development.

Four years later, it was now Colt that introduced the first successful double action revolver, the Model 1877 in two versions. Chambered in .38 Long Colt it was known as the Lightning, which was then followed by the Thunderer as the .41 Long Colt was known. Three years later, Smith & Wesson would add the double action feature to their Model #3.

By the end of the 1880s, the ball was back in Colt's court as they began a line of Army and Navy double action revolvers that were the first to have swing out cylinders. By the end of the century both Smith & Wesson and Colt had introduced their versions of the double action sixguns that would dominate much of the 20th century.

From Smith & Wesson came the first Military & Police in 1899, however, it had been superseded one year earlier by Colt's New Service. Smith & Wesson's modern revolver was built on a .38 platform that would become the K-frame; Colt went much larger. The New Service holds the distinction of not only being the largest revolver ever offered by Colt, it was also the largest revolver period, until the coming of Ruger's Redhawk and Dan Wesson's Model 44 in the 1980s.

Ten years after the introduction of the New Service, Smith & Wesson would counter with the first N-frame, the 1st Model Hand Ejector. For the first half of the 20th century, Colt's New Service .45 Colt and Smith & Wesson's Hand Ejectors in .44 Special would be worthy rivals.

The Legend Builds

The New Service actually overtook the Single Action Army in total production numbers due the fact more than 150,000 New Services chambered in .45 ACP with 5.5" barrels and known as the Model 1917 were ordered for the use in World War I. At the same time, Smith & Wesson was also producing their version of the Model 1917 using a 5.5" 2nd Model Hand Ejector.

In the late 1950s when I first discovered the joys of double action sixguns, both surplus models were still readily available, with excellent specimens going for $15. I tried them both and selected the Smith & Wesson due the simple fact the grip frame was better suited to my large, but short-fingered hand. If the New Service had any drawback it was the fact it was definitely made for those with large hands and long fingers.

While the Smith & Wesson Hand Ejectors were going through the process of 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th Models that would eventually lead to the .44 Magnum in 1955, Colt was also following an evolutionary path of standard models and several variations thereof.

Collectors now apply special terms to distinguish the various models of New Services from 1898 to 1941. The Old Model, the name applied to the first 21,000 New Services, was rather ungainly looking with a straight stovepipe-shaped barrel and a trigger guard looking like it was added-on as an afterthought.

After the Old Model, about 2,000 Transitional Models were offered with mainly interior improvements, including a hammer block safety. Next came the Improved Model, which would go to serial number 328,000 and is of course the New Service most often encountered. The barrel now had a larger collar where it screwed into the frame and the trigger guard was also larger and shaped to now look like it was actually part of the frame.

We can thank the United States Army for the collar on the barrel as all Model 1917s were ordered with the collar to provide a snug fit of barrel to frame. Designed for better function, it also resulted in a better form. Sometime around 1928 the Late Model New Service arrived with a change in the shape of the top strap to give it a more flattened appearance at the same time that the rear sight was milled to a square notch.

In the 1940 Colt catalog they offered three versions of the New Service. A standard model with barrel lengths of 4.5", 5.5" and 7.5" and either blue or nickel finish in .45 Colt, .45 ACP, .455 Eley, .44-40, .44 Special, .38 Special, .38-40, and the latest and most modern cartridge, the .357 Magnum. For some reason barrel lengths for the .38 Special and .357 Magnum were set at 4", 5" and 6".

Colt's advertising read, "The New Service is essentially a holster revolver for the man in the open-mounted Motorcycle and State Police; the Hunter, Explorer and Pioneer. It is the Arm adopted as Standard by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, and hundreds of city and state Police Organizations throughout the world."

The Colt was definitely a sixgun for both outdoor and duty use and it was adopted at the north and south ends of the country as the official sidearm of both the RCMP and the United States Border Patrol. The Mounties chose the .45 Colt, while our officers on the southern border had the New Service in .38 Special.