15 Fevrier 1839. - Review - movie review

TAKE ONE, May, 2001 by Maurie Alioff

2001 115m prod ACPAV, p Bernadette Payeur, Marc Daigle, disc Pierre Falardeau, ph Alain Dostie, ed Claude Palardy, pd Jean--Baptiste Tard, c Mario Davignon, s Mathieu Beaudin, Serge Beauchemin, Hans Peter Strobl, mus Jean St--Jacques; with Luc Picard, Sylvie Drapeau, Frederic Gilles, Jerry Snell, Julien Poulin

In the aftermath of the failed 1837--8 rebellion against England's rule over Quebec, 800 patriots are in the Prison de Montreal. The movie opens on February 14, 1839, the day when leader Marie Thomas Chevalier De Lormier and his comrade--in--arms, Swiss--born rebel Charles Hindelang are told they will hang in 24 hours.

The film portrays the last day in the lives of the two men as they interact with their fellow prisoners. Doomed, the patriots express their fears, discuss French--Canadian servitude (in ways that imply it continues today) and relentlessly insult their military guards ("You're shit," a rebel says in French to an uncomprehending tete carree). Black comic relief is provided when a quack doctor gives the men a mechanical examination and prescribes a useless medication. A guilt--stricken young guard tries to apologize to De Lormier who turns his back on him. The patriots pass the time with games, singing, dancing and their irrepressible joie de vivre.

De Lormier's wife visits him and insists that "Life is what matters, not words." After the two make love, she is dragged away. Despite his love for his wife, De Lormier's resolve is strengthened; he won't grovel for his captors. During a discussion about non--French Canadians in Quebec, one of De Lormier's comrades proclaims, "I don't care if you're white, black, yellow or green. I just want to know if you're on our side. If you are, you're a brother. If you're not, I hate you."

A last--supper sequence features jokes, rousing songs and poetic talk about sex. A kind--hearted priest arrives in the prison to give the men last rites. The next day, as the condemned are led to the gallows, De Lormier clutches his wife's red handkerchief. When he dies, it falls to the hard icy ground on a Quebec winter day.

15 fevrier 1839 time travels to the roots of Pierre Falardeau's chief passion in the movies and life. For the scrappy, unwaveringly grizzled independantiste, the 19th--century British colonization of French Canada shackled his people to a degrading subservience. Unless they wake up and get off their knees, they will perish.

In his previous films, Falardeau has looked at this urgent matter from multiple, overlapping angles. His 1990 film, Le Party, turned a hard--time penitentiary into a obvious metaphor for Quebec's political situation. 15 fevrier 1839 literalizes the incarceration motif of Le party, with its dank, claustrophobic Prison de Montreal setting. The inmates are guilty of no crime other than standing up for their identity. 15 fevrier also echoes the writer! director's 1994 film, Octobre, with the casting of Luc Picard as patriot leader, Chevalier De Lormier. In Octobre, Picard appeared as another brooding revolutionary during another crisis in Quebec history as one of the FLQ stalwarts who killed Pierre Laporte.

In addtion to these links, the heroic figure of De Lormier embodies all the values that are betrayed by Elvis Gratton, Falardeau's most famous creation. The cartoony Gratton, a pro-Canada imbecile with an insatiable jones for late Elvis Presley and other consumer goods, was played in three shorts and two features by Julien Poulin, Falardeau's close friend and long--time collaborator. In an allusive bit of casting, Poulin sheds his Elvis persona to appear in 15 fevrier as a saintly, pro--rebellion priest.

15 fevrier 1839 is Falardeau's dream project, the one obviously meant to be a mystical touchstone that illuminates his other work. As was described in Take One no. 31, he fought long and hard to make the picture, aided by young people who raised money and protested against Telefilm Canada's refusal to back him (the agency eventually recanted). Is 15 fevrier 1839 worth almost a decade of blood, sweat and tears? It's certainly not the masterpiece some independantiste viewers see in the film, but it's also not the insufferable, propagandistic dreck various English--language critics accuse it of being.

Shot in CinemaScope by ace director of photography Alain Dostie, the movie offers a vivid, often compelling picture of a colonized people's rage at their dispossession. The "goddamns" burned their houses, stole their land and savaged their sense of identity. Moreover, 15 fevrier's modern dialogue, including plenty of joual, is one of several anachronisms that gives the picture raw immediacy and connects with its audience. (As I write, it has grossed over $1 million, a shocker for those who predicted a box-office turkey.) And while the film sanctifies its dashing, romantic heroes, even flirting with religious nationalism, De Lormier and Hindelang are humanized: they are not sterile icons. As a call to arms, the movie puts some 1970s juice back into the cause after years of dry arguments about balance sheets and jurisdictions.