An index to measure and monitor a system-of-systems' performance risk

Defense AR Journal, Dec, 2005 by Paul R. Garvey, Chien-Ching Cho

TABLE 1. HYPOTHETICAL CATEGORY A & CATEGORY B TPM DATA SET

Category A TPM                                        Raw Value
                                           Vthres,A     V(ti,A)

Measurement Date t1
Average Processing Delay (msecs)              1.000       3.000
Mean Time to Repair (mins)                   10.000      50.000
Payload Weight (lbs)                        950.000    2112.000
Time for Engagement Coordination (sec)        0.010       0.100

                           TRI*(t1,A)         0.729      Eqt 9

Measurement Date t2
Average Processing Delay (msecs)              1.000       2.860
Mean Time to Repair (mins)                   10.000      43.000
Payload Weight (lbs)                        950.000    1764.000
Time for Engagement Coordination (sec)        0.010       0.040

                           TRI*(t2,A)         0.657      Eqt 9

Measurement Date t3
Average Processing Delay (msecs)              1.000       1.180
Mean Time to Repair (mins)                   10.000      43.000
Payload Weight (lbs)                        950.000    1328.000
Time for Engagement Coordination (sec)        0.010       0.032

                           TRI*(t3,A)         0.473      Eqt 9

Measurement Date t4
Average Processing Delay (msecs)              1.000       1.090
Mean Time to Repair (mins)                   10.000      27.000
Payload Weight (lbs)                        950.000    1189.000
Time for Engagement Coordination (sec)        0.010       0.020

                           TRI*(t4,A)         0.353      Eqt 9

Measurement Date t5
Average Processing Delay (msecs)              1.000       1.030
Mean Time to Repair (mins)                   10.000      12.000
Payload Weight (lbs)                        950.000    1008.000
Time for Engagement Coordination (sec)        0.010       0.010

                           TRI*(t5,A)         0.063      Eqt 9

Measurement Date t6
Average Processing Delay (msecs)              1.000       0.980
Mean Time to Repair (mins)                   10.000       9.000
Payload Weight (lbs)                        950.000     948.000
Time for Engagement Coordination (sec)        0.010       0.010

                           TrI*(t6,A)             0      Eqt 9

Category B TPM                                        Raw Value
                                           Vthres,B    V(ti,B)

Measurement Date t1
Interceptors Available (no. of units)       150.000      67.000
Mean Time Between Failure (hours)           500.000     100.000
Single Shot Success Probability (%)           0.950       0.870
Damage Assessment Accuracy (%)                0.995       0.600
Software Coding (no. of modules coded)      763.000     578.000

                           TRI(t2,B)          0.586     Eqt 10

Measurement Date t2
Interceptors Available (no. of units)       150.000     128.000
Mean Time Between Failure (hours)           500.000     189.000
Single Shot Success Probability (%)           0.950       0.890
Damage Assessment Accuracy (%)                0.995       0.878
Software Coding (no. of modules coded)      763.000     643.000

                           TRI(t2,B)          0.399     Eqt 10

Measurement Date t3
Interceptors Available (no. of units)       150.000     134.000
Mean Time Between Failure (hours)           500.000     223.000
Single Shot Success Probability (%)           0.950       0.910
Damage Assessment Accuracy (%)                0.995       0.940
Software Coding (no. of modules coded)      763.000     687.000

                           TRI(t3,B)          0.342     Eqt 10

Measurement Date t4
Interceptors Available (no. of units)       150.000     139.000
Mean Time Between Failure (hours)           500.000     348.000
Single Shot Success Probability (%)           0.950       0.934
Damage Assessment Accuracy (%)                0.995       0.945
Software Coding (no. of modules coded)      763.000     698.000

                           TRI(t4,B)          0.194     Eqt 10

Measurement Date t5
Interceptors Available (no. of units)       150.000     142.000
Mean Time Between Failure (hours)           500.000     379.000
Single Shot Success Probability (%)           0.950       0.940
Damage Assessment Accuracy (%)                0.995       0.999
Software Coding (no. of modules coded)      763.000     723.000

                           TRI(t5,B)          0.147     Eqt 10

Measurement Date t6
Interceptors Available (no. of units)       150.000     159.000
Mean Time Between Failure (hours)           500.000     521.000
Single Shot Success Probability (%)           0.950       0.990
Damage Assessment Accuracy (%)                0.995       1.000
Software Coding (no. of modules coded)      763.000     763.000

                           TRI(t6,B)              0     Eqt 10

Category A TPM                               Eqt 1       Eqt 5
                                           v(ti,A)     u(ti,A)      wt

Measurement Date t1
Average Processing Delay (msecs)              3.000       0.333   1.000
Mean Time to Repair (mins)                    5.000       0.200   1.000
Payload Weight (lbs)                          2.223       0.450   1.000
Time for Engagement Coordination (sec)       10.000       0.100   1.000

                           TRI*(t1,A)

Measurement Date t2
Average Processing Delay (msecs)              2.860       0.350   1.000
Mean Time to Repair (mins)                    4.300       0.233   1.000
Payload Weight (lbs)                          1.857       0.539   1.000
Time for Engagement Coordination (sec)        4.000       0.250   1.000

                           TRI*(t2,A)

Measurement Date t3
Average Processing Delay (msecs)              1.180       0.847   1.000
Mean Time to Repair (mins)                    4.300       0.233   1.000
Payload Weight (lbs)                          1.398       0.715   1.000
Time for Engagement Coordination (sec)        3.200       0.313   1.000

                           TRI*(t3,A)

Measurement Date t4
Average Processing Delay (msecs)              1.090       0.917   1.000
Mean Time to Repair (mins)                    2.700       0.370   1.000
Payload Weight (lbs)                          1.252       0.799   1.000
Time for Engagement Coordination (sec)        2.000       0.500   1.000

                           TRI*(t4,A)

Measurement Date t5
Average Processing Delay (msecs)              1.030       0.971   1.000
Mean Time to Repair (mins)                    1.200       0.833   1.000
Payload Weight (lbs)                          1.061       0.942   1.000
Time for Engagement Coordination (sec)        1.000       1.000   1.000

                           TRI*(t5,A)

Measurement Date t6
Average Processing Delay (msecs)              1.000       1.000   1.000
Mean Time to Repair (mins)                    1.000       1.000   1.000
Payload Weight (lbs)                          1.000       1.000   1.000
Time for Engagement Coordination (sec)        1.000       1.000   1.000

                           TrI*(t6,A)

Category B TPM                               Eqt 2
                                           v(ti,B)          wt

Measurement Date t1
Interceptors Available (no. of units)         0.447       1.000
Mean Time Between Failure (hours)             0.200       5.000
Single Shot Success Probability (%)           0.916       1.000
Damage Assessment Accuracy (%)                0.603       1.000
Software Coding (no. of modules coded)        0.758       1.000

                           TRI(t2,B)

Measurement Date t2
Interceptors Available (no. of units)         0.853       1.000
Mean Time Between Failure (hours)             0.378       5.000
Single Shot Success Probability (%)           0.937       1.000
Damage Assessment Accuracy (%)                0.882       1.000
Software Coding (no. of modules coded)        0.843       1.000

                           TRI(t2,B)

Measurement Date t3
Interceptors Available (no. of units)         0.893       1.000
Mean Time Between Failure (hours)             0.446       5.000
Single Shot Success Probability (%)           0.958       1.000
Damage Assessment Accuracy (%)                0.945       1.000
Software Coding (no. of modules coded)        0.900       1.000

                           TRI(t3,B)

Measurement Date t4
Interceptors Available (no. of units)         0.927       1.000
Mean Time Between Failure (hours)             0.696       5.000
Single Shot Success Probability (%)           0.983       1.000
Damage Assessment Accuracy (%)                0.950       1.000
Software Coding (no. of modules coded)        0.915       1.000

                           TRI(t4,B)

Measurement Date t5
Interceptors Available (no. of units)         0.947       1.000
Mean Time Between Failure (hours)             0.758       5.000
Single Shot Success Probability (%)           0.989       1.000
Damage Assessment Accuracy (%)                1.000       1.000
Software Coding (no. of modules coded)        0.948       1.000

                           TRI(t5,B)

Measurement Date t6
Interceptors Available (no. of units)         1.000       1.000
Mean Time Between Failure (hours)             1.000       5.000
Single Shot Success Probability (%)           1.000       1.000
Damage Assessment Accuracy (%)                1.000       1.000
Software Coding (no. of modules coded)        1.000       1.000

                           TRI(t6,B)

TABLE 2. TPM RISK INDEX SUMMARIES

Measurement    TPM Risk Index     TPM Risk Index    Overall TPM Risk
   Date        for Category A     for Category B         Index
                    TPMs               TPMs
              [TRI*.sub.ti, A]   [TRI*.sub.ti, B]   [TRI*.sub.ti, AI]
                   Eqt 9              Eqt 10             Eqt 11

    t1             0.729              0.586               0.63
    t2             0.657              0.399              0.478
    t3             0.473              0.342              0.382
    t4             0.353              0.194              0.243
    t5             0.063              0.147              0.121
    t6               0                  0                  0
COPYRIGHT 2005 Defense Acquisition University Press
COPYRIGHT 2006 Gale Group
 

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)

advertisement
Click Here
advertisement
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
  • Click Here
advertisement

Content provided in partnership with Thompson Gale